The Nutrition Data Blog

About this blog About this blog Subscribe (RSS) Subscribe (RSS)

Can you store up enough vitamin D in the summer to last you though winter?

Mpj043839700001 Q. Is vitamin D stored in the body and if so, for how long? If I get 3-5 hours of direct sunlight per day during the summer, will I have enough vitamin D in my body to last me the rest of the year, or will I still need to get some from diet and/or supplementation?

A. Your body has only a limited capacity to store vitamin D and the effects of sun exposure on vitamin D levels only last a week or two at most. So, sunbathing in the summer will not get you through the winter.  And vitamin D deficiency is a serious problem, as we discussed in this recent blog post.  The average American diet provides far less than the recommended 400IU per day, and a consensus is building that even 400IU per day is woefully inadequate.

I just ran across this long but well-referenced article by Krispin Sullivan, posted at the Weston Price Foundation website, that goes into quite a bit of detail on every aspect of this issue.  I highly recommend the article for anyone attempting to meet their vitamin D requirements via sun exposure. For example, you'll learn that while you can get a sunburn from both UV-A and UV-B rays, you can only make vitamin D from UV-B.

While UV-A is present all day long, UV-B is only present at mid-day, unless you live in the tropics.  So, if you are sunning for vitamin D, you need to do it at mid-day (between 10 am and 2 pm). If you sun yourself before or after that time, you will get a sunburn (from UV-A) before you get enough UV-B to maximize vitamin D production.

Even during those hours, how much vitamin D you can produce depends on your skin type, your age, your latitude, your altitude [with a shout-out to faithful reader and astute observer Jim Kent: you said it first!], how much of your body is exposed, etc.  But get this: For less than $200, you can buy a UV-B meter that will actually calculate how many IU of vitamin D3 you are producing per minute!

Here's another fascinating tip: To maximize vitamin D levels, don't take a shower or get in the pool for an hour after sun exposure. Right after you are exposed to the sun, the vitamin D is still in the oils in your skin and can be washed away before it is absorbed into the blood.

Back to your question: Unless you live in the tropics, you will definitely need another source of vitamin D to get you through the winter, either food sources or supplements. And here's a very important point about vitamin D supplementation brought up in the article linked to above.

Sullivan notes that supplementing with vitamin D not only increases your absorption of calcium but will also increase your absorption of lead, arsenic, and cadmium if your levels of calcium, magnesium, and phosphorus are inadequate. So, if you are going to take a vitamin D supplement, be sure that your intake of these nutrients (from either diet or supplementation) is also sufficient!

read more articles like this: Ask Monica: Nutrition Questions Answered
COMMENTS:

Posted by: Dave | Jul 2, 2008 1:00:17 PM

Excellent info on Vitamin D can be found here: http://vitamindcouncil.org/

Posted by: Edward Hutchinson | Jul 3, 2008 2:55:48 PM

I am sure that Krispin Sullivan is mistaken in her understanding of the way vitamin d is made on the skin surface.

The process is explained in detail with animated diagrams here http://www.uvguide.co.uk/vitdpathway.htm

You will see the process is carried out under the surface of the skin in the lower layers of the epidermis and therefore showering/swimming while sunbathing should not waste a significant amount of the vitamin d.

It may be true that as converting previtamin d to Vitamin D3 is heat driven this conversion will continue while the skin is hot. Therefore sudden cooling of the skin will end this process. But the process vitamin d synthesis as the process is self-limiting. Once D3 is made, further heat turns the surplus D3 that is not absorbed, into substances that are not readily used.
So this is one of those situations where one cannot be sure if staying out too long in the sun will overcook the Vitamin d anyway, or whether having a cold shower/swim stops the vitamin D from being converted into products the body cannot use.

I think it shows it's probably best to have as many short sessions in the sun/under UVB lights as possible.

Posted by: Edward Hutchinson | Jul 3, 2008 3:08:00 PM

Can I suggest those who are interested in learning more should study this paper.
Circulating Vitamin D3 and 25-hydroxyvitamin D in Humans
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?tool=pubmed&pubmedid=17218096

In particular study the plots in the figures to see that the storage of Vitamin D3 is only started after the body's daily needs have been fully met, above the 125nmol/l 50ng mark.

Heaney has shown inhttp://www.ajcn.org/cgi/content/full/77/1/204
Human serum 25-hydroxycholecalciferol response to extended oral dosing with cholecalciferol the body uses 3000-5000iu daily and as each 1000iu/daily raises status 10ng you see that 5000iu/daily is required to reach 50ng and at this point the body starts storing D3 in significant amounts.

The half life of D3 is roughly 3 weeks. You therefore need to store a considerable amount to remain sufficient through the winter.

Imagine if as well as being required to spend $5000/daily your bank reduced your savings capital by 50% every 21 days starting at the end of September and ending at the end of March.

I'm sure someone can work out how much you need to survive the winter and remain in credit but it's going to require millions. Simpler to use an effective strength 5000iu/d supplement when UVB isn't an option.

Posted by: Jim Kent | Jul 7, 2008 8:12:12 PM

Wow, I might have to check out that meter.

I did a bit more research on PubMed, and as far as I can tell, it's not the case that when the sun gets too low you no longer can make vitamin D. It is true that the UV-A/UV-B level will change, and that the UV-B level falls off more quickly as the sun lowers than the UV-A level does. The idea that you could get sunburned from the UV-A before you made enough vitamin D from the UV-B looks like it could be true if you were only exposed to close-to-the-horizon sun just on a limited area of your body (like face and hands).

THere's a neat calculator, not as accurate as the meter I imagine, but free and quick over the web at http://nadir.nilu.no/~olaeng/fastrt/VitD_quartMED.html. This will calculate how long you need to be exposed to the sun to get enough D. It looks like on the winter solstice in New York City you can still get your RDA (400) of D from 1 hours exposure of 10% of your body (face and hands) to the sun around midday.

The pubMed search did confirm a statement I saw here, that exposing mushrooms to the sun causes them to synthesize vitamin D. It also turned up a very neat fact - the shade of a tree or an umbrella only reduces the vitamin D synthesis by half over full sun. (See Vitamin D effective ultraviolet wavelengths due to scattering in shade by Turnbull DJ, Parisi AV, Kimlin MG.) UV-B refracts so much that having a line of sight to blue sky is enough to get you quite a bit of D synthesis. (Refraction - it's the physical phenomenon where shorter wave lengths of light bend more. It's why a prism makes a rainbow and actually why the sky looks blue most of the time, and red during sunset....)

Anyway, if you are going to do a D supplement you might consider cod liver oil. It sounds gross and tastes gross (get it in capsules), and perhaps the poor cod are overfished as well. On the other hand you'll end up with omega-3's as well as the D, and probably a few other fat-soluble things that keep polar bears and eskimos healthy during the winter arctic months.

Posted by: Family Nutritionist | Jul 8, 2008 10:36:55 AM

I'm not sure the Weston Price author was correct about washing away vitamin D in the shower. According to the abstract of the paper he cited for that paragraph (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/6265564), the previtamin D3 synthesis occurs in the cells of the stratum Malpighii (or mucosum), which is just above the stratum basale in the epidermis (http://www.dermatologyinfo.net/english/images/chapters_img/3b.jpg). The sebaceous gands, where skin oils are made, are deeper, in the dermis(http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/34/Skin.jpg).

Posted by: Bonnie Stevens | Jul 15, 2008 12:29:20 AM

I have found the most interesting book written about Vitamin D. You may want to visit www.alsearsmd.com.
He has a book which you can purchase
to read online or in printed version.
I have read almost all of his books and they are fantastic. The doctor is
very well credentialed and he has written some excellent articles and published several great books on maintaining heart health and staying
physically and emotionally fit. He also produces a very informative newaletter which is free. Enjoy:)

Posted by: christoff | Sep 6, 2008 11:19:11 PM

Hi Jim Kent, I cant seem to find any evidence proving that "the shade of a tree or an umbrella only reduces the vitamin D synthesis by half over full sun.", and "UV-B refracts so much that having a line of sight to blue sky is enough to get you quite a bit of D synthesis."

Do you know where you got these facts?

Posted by: Mariann | Oct 28, 2008 6:30:03 PM

If I am supplementing with vitamin D how long can I wait until I get a blood test to see where my viitamin D levels are? It sounds like it could take a few months to get an accurate test, if that is true why would it take this long?

Posted by: Scott Miller, Auburndale, FL | Oct 29, 2008 12:33:49 PM

Jim Kent - Here is an excerpt on the shade theory: http://www.atmos-chem-phys-discuss.net/8/781/2008/acpd-8-781-2008-print.pdf

POST A COMMENT

Home
Ask Monica Ask Monica Previously asked nutrition questions Previously asked nutrition questions
Dr. Steve Parker answers your heart health questions
BLOGS OF INTEREST
About Nutrition Data Contact Us Advertising Press Center Site Map

Condé Nast Web sites

Epicurious / Concierge / Hotel Chatter / Jaunted / Style.com / Men.Style.com / Wired.com / Reddit / Ars Technica / Webmonkey


Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement (revised 8/20/08) and Privacy Policy (revised 8/20/08). NutritionData.com © 2009 Condé Nast Digital. All rights reserved. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached, or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Condé Nast Digital.